Top five most overrated Manchester City players in recent history
Most overrated Manchester City players? Who are the Most overrated Manchester City players? Which Manchester City players are the most overrated? We have compiled a list of the top five most overrated players at Manchester City. So which Manchester City players are not as good as everyone thinks they are? Well you’re going to find out.
Top 5 most overrated Manchester City players
Many great players have come and gone at Manchester City. Some became legends such as Sergio Aguero and Kevin De Bruyne. While others were just not as good as everyone thought they were. Here is the list of the top five most overrated Manchester City players.
5. Benjamin Mendy – Most overrated Manchester City players
The French left back was brought in from AS Monaco. He was one of the best players in the Ligue 1 campaign when Monaco rampaged their way to the title by beating PSG. It resulted in a bidding war for Mendy and it was City who won that battle.
Pep was desperate for a new left back as he was not impressed with Aleksandr Kolarov. Eventually Kolarov was shipped off to Serie A and Mendy came in. He made a bright and impressive debut at City but was soon on the fringes of the first team action.
It was a result of overconfident play and injuries. A modern footballer needs to be at the top of his physical health to look after his fitness and Mendy while unlucky with some injuries, did not do that on a regular level or a regular basis.
Mendy also failed to adapt to the English Premier League, which was faster and more physical than the French league. It requires players to have more attention at all seconds since games change at the drop of a hat and Mendy was not up to it.
Finally it was also a matter of playing under the system of Pep Guardiola which turned out to be very tough for Benjamin. The discipline and energy levels needed were simply too much for him.
He is still a part of the City contingent and trying to make a regular return to the starting XI, but Pep still doubts him over big matches – a sad situation for a player who was once the world’s most expensive full back.
4. Nathan Ake – Most overrated Manchester City players
It was the era of left-backs as another full-back in Joao Cancelo joined Bayern Munich on a six-month loan deal. So Pep Guardiola had to deploy central defender Nathan Ake in the left-back position.
When Pep joined City, did not win any major trophies and while he never directly called anyone out, it was clear that he was not happy with the full back service and wanted an overhaul. And City’s Sheikh owners spent a lavish 150 million pounds to bring in Kyle Walker, Danilo and Benjamin Mendy for Pep Guardiola.
While Walker has been a very big hit, we already discussed Mendy has not, and Guardiola definitely needs a serious presence on the left-flank this summer.
Ake was not ready for the Premier League level and made one error too many both in defence and in attack. He loved to bomb forward with the ball at his feet but very rarely had the intuition to release it at the right time or with the right pace or precision.
3. Kalvin Phillips- Most overrated Manchester City players
While he is considered a valuable midfielder, a closer look will reveal that he has started only two games for the Cityzens and played 15 times in all competitions. In the national team, he plays with the likes of Henderson and Rice who put up chances for him regularly while at City, the likes of Rodri and Gundogan derailed his chances of getting into the first-team squad. He played 38 minutes last month against Leicester City which was his highest total in a single Premier League match for the Cityzens.
Yes, one can argue, he is young, however, he has arrived at the Etihad last summer and would need a few more seasons to prove his potential.
2. Rodri – Most overrated Manchester City players
Brought in to replace Fernandinho, it was never going to be an easy task. However, the Spaniard seems to make his job harder for himself. He definitely does not have Fernandinho’s drive to move forward but even while playing small passes or stopping counter-attacks, his quality is nowhere near that of Fernandinho. There is hope he wil lean and get better but he is already 26 and he has to improve fast.
1. Jack Grealish – Most overrated Manchester City players
We understand this will not be a popular opinion. However, the UK media places Grealish as one of the best attackers in the league and in the top 10 in the world. We definitely feel he is good, but nowhere near the top 10 even in the world. As for Premier League, there is Saka, Mahrez, Martinelli, Salah, Auba, Rashford – who all are in our opinion better than Grealish.
Jack Grealish does produce brilliant numbers but he misses too many sitters and is too shabby in front of goal to be a world class finisher or a winger.